Beware! The “New and Revised,” “Phantom of the Opera,” should read a “Severely” Scaled Down, Cheaper Version, that Lacks its original, Brilliance and Ambiance!
There’s a reason why the original stage production of Andrew Lloyd Webber’s “The Phantom of the Opera” became an instantaneous hit in 1988 when it first opened on Broadway at the Majestic theater, in New York City. Reviewers called the show, “one of the most visually stunning theatrical productions” to ever grace the stage. “The Phantom of the Opera” went on to win seven Tony Awards including: best musical, best costume design, best lighting, best direction, best scenic design, best actress (Judy Kaye,) and best actor, given to Michael Crawford. “The Phantom of the Opera,” is also the longest running operatic musical in Broadway’s history.
The basic element to “The Phantom of the Opera’s” original success, is, of course, Andrew Lloyd Webber’s beloved, musical score. In the original production, the music was enhanced with an orchestra accompanying the exquisite vocals. This combination of live voices and instruments created a unique gothic musical experience that heightened the audience’s senses from beginning to end.
Equally mesmerizing was “The Phantom of the Opera’s” iconic, Tony Award winning, visual presentation. Although these elements were kept to a bare minimum, the impact of the sets, creative staging, lighting, elaborate costumes, along with the special effects, convoked the audience to forget their surroundings and fully surrender to The Phantom’s haunting ambiance.
So why on earth was this incredible theatrical production “revised” in the UK in 2012, then brought to tour in the US in 2025?
Financial stress brought about by covid and the entertainment industries additional hardships such as union strikes, fueled the decision to drastically cut costs in order to keep the mobile production touring.
Unfortunately, in the process of scaling down the financial costs, they have bruised the production and stripped “The Phantom of the Opera” of its artistic glory! For theater goers, this is a great loss!
In the original presentation, audience members took their seats, and were greeted by a huge, golden winged angel, inspired by the Palais Garnier in Paris, positioned in the center top of the proscenium stage. Next to it, on both sides of the upper proscenium, golden human-like satyrs and nymphs, some of them gazing out at the audience, created a menacingly mythological sensation that hauntingly sent a preparatory rush of excitement running through the audience’s veins. Like a delicious appetizer preluding a gourmet meal. These images foretold that you were about to experience something distinctly memorable.
The first adrenaline rush in the original show is when the large, impressive crystal chandelier begins to teeter totter, hovering precariously over the audience for a few heart-stopping seconds before crashing down on the stage. Immediately, Webber’s famous overture accompanies a creative transformation that takes the audience out of the auction scene into the Paris opera house.
Both the original and new production include Christine’s dressing room which features a magical full length, dressing mirror. Through this mirror, the Phantom casts his spell on Christine and we watch her step into the mirror’s shadowed glass and disappear.
What happened next was one of the most iconic moments in theater history!
The stage becomes ominously haunting, and we watch the Phantom transport Christine to his lair, in a boat through an underground lake. The boat moves slowly across the stage enveloped with a ghostly fog that is lit with the mystical glow of eerie candles, while the Phantom and Christine performed the shows signature song, “The Phantom of the Opera.”
When the revised version began its tour, two of my nieces were visiting me from out-of-town. Neither of them had seen the stage version of “The Phantom of the Opera,” but because of the wonderful things they heard about the show, it was top of their “theatrical” bucket list, so I purchased tickets for the three of us.
The first indication that this was going to be a very different production was the disappointing stark stage proscenium. The exotic golden embellishments were gone. As the show unfolded, it continued to disappoint. The chandelier was replaced with into a lighter, safer version, but sadly, these adjustments have also diminished the excitement to this impactful moment.
I couldn’t believe it when the iconic lake scene was completely restaged to nothing except for a fire escape that was cast in darkness with heavy shadows and pushed so far upstage you couldn’t see the actor’s faces as they sang.
Gone are the spectacular special effects along with the old gothic eeriness and mystical romanticism that the show once possessed. Even the orchestra has fewer musicians and now utilizes recorded musical segments.
I left the theater angered! The tickets were expensive, and I wanted my money back! I vowed that I would never purchase a ticket for this severely disappointing version again. My nieces were equally unimpressed and confused. The show they saw fell short in every aspect to representing the production they had heard so much about and anticipated.
Broadway justifies their revisions by stating that they have created a more “movie-like” experience of the show, with a darker, more realistic atmosphere.” If someone wants a “movie-like” experience, they should watch the beautiful movie version, staring Gerard Butler as the Phantom and Emmy Rossum. People go to Broadway for the “stage” experience, not a movie!
Today, the revised “The Phantom of the Opera” is still making national tours. But if you decide to purchase a ticket, keep in mind that this is not the production that so many of us fell in love with and have raved about for decades!
And beware of the other theatrical productions that are advertising “New and Revised!” These new versions of classical stage productions, such as Rodger’s and Hammerstein’s, “Cinderella” and “Oklahoma,” have been altered to the point where it’s difficult to determine what the original script was like. Original songs and characters are being removed and replaced with gaps and less impactful music. The musical “Oklahoma” which used to be “family friendly,” is no longer appropriate for children!

































